Immune Tolerance & The Development of Autoimmunity

The immune system functions as a highly selective defence network, recognising foreign pathogens while preserving self-tolerance to avoid attacking the body’s own tissues. This balance is essential for immune homeostasis—but when tolerance mechanisms break down, autoimmune diseases develop, causing chronic inflammation and tissue destruction.

Understanding how immune tolerance is established, maintained, and eventually fails provides critical insight into the pathophysiology of autoimmunity.

🔬 Immune Tolerance: Preventing Self-Destruction

Immune tolerance is a multi-layered system designed to prevent inappropriate immune activation against self-antigens. It operates through:

✅ Central tolerance—eliminating autoreactive lymphocytes early in primary immune organs.

✅ Peripheral tolerance—regulating autoreactive cells in circulation and tissues.

1️⃣ Central Tolerance: Educating Immune Cells in Primary Lymphoid Organs

Before lymphocytes are released into circulation, they undergo selection processes in the thymus (T cells) and bone marrow (B cells) to eliminate autoreactive clones.

✅ Negative Selection:

• Auto-reactive T and B cells that bind self-antigens too strongly undergo apoptosis.
• This prevents autoreactive clones from escaping into circulation.

✅ Positive Selection:

• T cells that appropriately recognise self-MHC molecules survive, ensuring proper immune responses.

💡 Clinical Correlation: Defects in negative selection increase the likelihood of autoimmune disease. This is seen in Autoimmune Polyendocrine Syndrome Type 1 (APS-1), where mutations in AIRE fail to eliminate autoreactive clones.

2️⃣ Peripheral Tolerance: Keeping the Immune Response in Check

Even after negative selection, some self-reactive lymphocytes escape central tolerance. Peripheral tolerance mechanisms prevent them from causing damage in tissues.

✅ Anergy:

• Auto-reactive lymphocytes become non-functional when they encounter self-antigens without proper co-stimulation.

✅ Regulatory T cells (Tregs):

• Suppress excessive immune activation via IL-10 & TGF-β cytokines.

✅ Activation-Induced Cell Death (AICD):

• Repeated activation leads to apoptosis of autoreactive clones, preventing uncontrolled immune responses.

💡 Clinical Correlation: Dysfunctional Tregs contribute to autoimmune diseases like Type 1 Diabetes, where self-reactive cells attack pancreatic β-cells, leading to insulin deficiency

Want more detail? Immunopaedia explains it well ! 
https://www.immunopaedia.org.za/immunology/advanced/2-central-peripheral-tolerance/ 

⚡ Mechanisms Leading to Autoimmunity: How Does Immune Tolerance Fail?

When immune tolerance fails, self-reactive lymphocytes escape regulation, leading to autoimmune disorders. Several key mechanisms underlie the breakdown of tolerance:

🔹 Genetic Susceptibility & HLA Associations

• Certain HLA alleles predispose individuals to autoimmunity—These genetic markers influence antigen presentation, shaping immune responses toward autoreactivity.

🔹 Molecular Mimicry

• Some pathogens share antigenic similarities with self-tissues, triggering cross-reactivity.

🔹 Epitope Spreading

• Tissue injury exposes hidden antigens, widening the immune attack.

🔹 Environmental Triggers & Dysregulated Immune Signalling

• Smoking, UV exposure, viral infections, and gut microbiome imbalance alter immune regulation, worsening autoimmune risk.

💡 Key Takeaway: Autoimmune disease arises from a complex interplay of genetics, environmental factors, and defective regulatory pathways.

1️⃣ Genetic Predisposition & Autoimmune Risk

While environmental factors contribute to autoimmune disease, genetic susceptibility plays a foundational role in shaping immune regulation and antigen recognition.

🔹 HLA & Autoimmunity: The Genetic Gatekeepers

The human leukocyte antigen (HLA) complex, located on chromosome 6, is a major determinant of self-recognition and immune response. Certain HLA haplotypes dramatically increase autoimmune susceptibility:

• HLA-DR4 → Strongly linked to Rheumatoid Arthritis.
• HLA-B27 → Associated with Ankylosing Spondylitis and Reactive Arthritis.
• HLA-DR3 & HLA-DR2 → Increases risk for Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (SLE) and Multiple Sclerosis (MS).
• HLA-DQ2/DQ8 → Found in nearly 95% of individuals with Coeliac Disease.

🔹 Why Does HLA Affect Autoimmunity?

HLA molecules present antigens to T cells, shaping immune responses. Certain HLA variants:

• Over-present self-antigens, promoting auto-reactive T-cell activation.
• Interact with environmental triggers, enhancing disease risk (e.g., HLA-B27 and gut microbial dysbiosis in spondyloarthropathies).
• Influence cytokine signalling, altering immune regulation.

💡 Example: HLA-B27 misfolding triggers endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress, activating the unfolded protein response (UPR)—a mechanism implicated in Ankylosing Spondylitis pathogenesis.

💡 Key Takeaway: While HLA genes influence autoimmune risk, additional genetic mutations (e.g., PTPN22 in RA, IL-2Rα in MS) fine-tune disease susceptibility.

2️⃣ Environmental Triggers: Breaking Immune Tolerance

Autoimmune diseases are rarely purely genetic—they require environmental factors to precipitate immune dysregulation. Several key triggers initiate or exacerbate autoimmunity:

🔬 Viral & Bacterial Infections: Immune System Hijacking

Certain infections stimulate autoimmunity via molecular mimicry, bystander activation, and epitope spreading.

🔹 Molecular Mimicry:

• Pathogens share antigenic structures with host proteins, leading to cross-reactivity.
• Example: Group A Streptococcal (GAS) infections triggering Rheumatic Fever, where bacterial M proteins resemble cardiac antigens, leading to autoimmune heart damage.
• Epstein–Barr virus (EBV) infection → Potential trigger for SLE and Multiple Sclerosis, altering immune memory.
  
  
  

🔹 Bystander Activation:

• Infections activate non-specific immune cells, leading to collateral tissue damage.
• Coxsackievirus B → Associated with Type 1 Diabetes, triggering β-cell destruction.

🔹 Epitope Spreading:

• Persistent infection causes antigen release, widening auto-reactivity.
• Example: Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (SLE)—immune responses initially target nuclear material from apoptotic cells, but inflammation amplifies immune activation, and exposes more hidden nuclear antigen leading to multi-organ damage.

🚬 Smoking & Autoimmune Risk: The Pro-Inflammatory Catalyst

Smoking induces oxidative stress, alters mucosal immunity, and increases susceptibility to autoimmune diseases:

• Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA) → Strong correlation between smoking and citrullinated protein formation, promoting anti-CCP autoantibodies.
• SLE & Vasculitis → Smoking alters T-cell function, increasing risk for vascular inflammation.

🦠 Gut Dysbiosis & Autoimmune Activation

The gut microbiome is a critical regulator of immune tolerance—imbalances in microbial populations contribute to immune dysfunction.

• Reduced diversity of gut bacteria weakens Regulatory T-cell (Treg) function, heightening autoimmunity.
• Dysbiosis in Ankylosing Spondylitis → HLA-B27 interactions with microbiota enhance IL-23-driven inflammation.
• Coeliac Disease → Gluten-driven gut inflammation promotes T-cell activation against enterocytes.

💡 Key Clinical Insight: Autoimmune patients often exhibit altered gut microbial signatures, making microbiome-targeted therapies an area of growing interest.

3️⃣ Mechanisms of Immune Tolerance Failure

Loss of immune tolerance is central to autoimmune pathogenesis—here’s how tolerance mechanisms fail:

⚠️ Breakdown of Regulatory T-Cell (Treg) Function

Tregs, marked by CD25+ and FOXP3, play a critical role in immune suppression.

• Loss of Tregs leads to unchecked inflammation, seen in SLE, Type 1 Diabetes, and RA.
• Mutations in FOXP3 (IPEX Syndrome) result in severe multi-organ autoimmunity.
• IL-10 and TGF-β signalling defects impair immune resolution, amplifying auto-reactivity.

💡 Example: Individuals with defective Treg function often show persistent inflammatory cytokine elevation, worsening disease progression.

⚠️ Defective Anergy: Failure to Shut Down Auto-Reactive Cells

Anergy is the process of rendering auto-reactive lymphocytes inactive.

• Without proper co-stimulation (CD80/CD86), T cells should become anergic.
• Autoimmune patients often show ‘revived’ auto-reactive T cells, contributing to chronic disease.

💡 Example: In RA, autoreactive Th17 cells escape anergy, perpetuating synovial inflammation via IL-17 secretion.

⚠️ Autoantibody Generation: The Loss of B-Cell Self-Regulation

When tolerance mechanisms fail, B cells produce autoantibodies, targeting self-tissues.

• Loss of B-cell central tolerance → Anti-nuclear antibodies (ANA) in SLE.
• Self-antigen exposure leads to epitope spreading, worsening disease.
• Defective germinal centre reactions allow escape of autoreactive clones, increasing autoantibody burden.

💡 Example: In MS, autoreactive B cells produce anti-myelin antibodies, leading to demyelination.

🔬 Key Autoimmune Diseases & Their Pathophysiology

🚑 Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (SLE) - more details in a future blog post !

• Auto-reactive B cells produce anti-nuclear antibodies (ANA), leading to immune complex deposition in tissues.
• Cytokine dysregulation (IL-6, IFN-α) fuels chronic inflammation, driving tissue damage.

🚑 Type 1 Diabetes Mellitus

• CD8+ T cells attack pancreatic β-cells, causing insulin deficiency.
• Loss of peripheral tolerance allows autoreactive T cells to proliferate unchecked, leading to progressive β-cell destruction.

🚑 Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA)

• TNF-α and IL-6 drive synovial inflammation, leading to joint destruction.
• Autoantibodies (RF, Anti-CCP) contribute to ongoing immune activation and progressive erosive arthritis.

🚑 Multiple Sclerosis (MS)

• T-cell-mediated destruction of myelin impairs neural transmission, disrupting motor and sensory function.
• B-cell involvement (oligoclonal bands in CSF) confirms immune dysregulation, contributing to neuroinflammation.

🚑 Hashimoto’s Thyroiditis

• Auto-antibodies against thyroperoxidase (TPO) destroy thyroid tissue, leading to hypothyroidism.
• Chronic lymphocytic infiltration progressively damages thyroid function.

🚑 Graves’ Disease

• Stimulating auto-antibodies (TSH receptor Abs) mimic TSH, causing uncontrolled thyroid activation and hyperthyroidism.
•  Leads to thyroid hypertrophy, ophthalmopathy, and metabolic dysfunction.

💡 Clinical Consideration:

Autoimmune diseases are often multi-factorial—consider genetic predisposition, environmental triggers, and immune dysregulation in differential diagnosis.

🔎 Final Thoughts: The Delicate Balance Between Immunity & Tolerance

Immune tolerance safeguards against self-destruction, but its failure leads to devastating autoimmune diseases. While genetic predisposition creates susceptibility, environmental factors often act as triggers, breaking tolerance and leading to disease.

👩‍⚕️ Clinical Thinking:

• When evaluating unexplained inflammation or multi-system disease, always consider autoimmune pathology.
• Genetic HLA typing may provide insights into disease susceptibility.
• Identifying modifiable environmental risk factors (smoking, infections, gut dysbiosis) may help disease prevention and early intervention.

#Immunology #Autoimmunity #MedicalEducation #FutureDoctors #Medschool #Immunology